Signs You Are Compatible
You are likely compatible when each of you trusts the other's commitment, feels appreciated, argues without contempt and makes up after a fight; large studies of couples tie these most closely to how satisfied people are. The signs you are not compatible are the mirror image: contempt, stonewalling and repairs that keep failing.
Signs are the outside view of what compatibility means, the fit of two people's everyday defaults. The two lists below describe what researchers could see in couples who were satisfied and couples who were not. They describe patterns, not verdicts on a person.
To compare the areas directly, a relationship compatibility questionnaire scores nine of them from both partners' answers, and each of you answers on your own phone.
What are the signs you are compatible?
The seven signs below come from two places: the largest study of couples to date, and the Gottman Institute's work on how couples argue and make up.
- You trust each other's commitment. Each of you believes the other is in it for the long run. (Joel and colleagues, 2020)
- You feel appreciated, and you show it. Gratitude runs both ways, often in small things. (Joel and colleagues, 2020)
- You think your partner is happy with you. You do not have to guess whether they are satisfied. (Joel and colleagues, 2020)
- Arguments stay about the problem. Disagreements happen without contempt or name-calling. (Joel and colleagues, 2020; the Gottman Institute)
- You make up after a fight. A joke, an apology or a hand on the arm stops things escalating, and it works. (The Gottman Institute on repair attempts)
- You are both content with your intimate life. Physical closeness is something you are both happy with and can talk about. (Joel and colleagues, 2020)
- You feel alike where it counts. You see yourselves as similar, whatever a checklist says. (Montoya and colleagues, 2008)
Five of the seven come from the 2020 study of 11,196 couples, which found that judgments like these explained about 45 percent of how satisfied people were. None of them is a trait you either have or lack. The Gottman Institute defines a repair attempt as "any statement or action, silly or otherwise, that prevents negativity from escalating out of control".
Does sharing values make you compatible?
Less than people think. In a study of 291 newlywed couples, partners were alike in their attitudes, but that likeness did not go with a better marriage, while likeness in personality did (Luo and Klohnen, 2005). A review of 313 studies found that actual similarity stopped predicting attraction once people were in a relationship, while feeling similar kept predicting it (Montoya and colleagues, 2008). Shared values and goals still belong in a couple's conversations, which is why the couple quiz asks about both. The research point is narrower: measured sameness, on its own, is a weak sign.
What are the signs you are not compatible?
The signs you are not compatible mirror the first list. The first four are what the Gottman Institute calls the Four Horsemen.
- Contempt. Eye-rolling, mockery and sarcasm aimed at the person. The Gottman Institute calls contempt the single greatest predictor of divorce.
- Criticism of the person. A complaint about someone's character rather than about what happened.
- Defensiveness. Every complaint meets an excuse or a counter-complaint, so none of them lands.
- Stonewalling. One partner shuts down or leaves the conversation.
- Repairs that keep failing. Attempts to calm things down are ignored or turned away. The Institute's blog calls the consistent failure of repair attempts "a sign of an unhappy future".
- Doubt about commitment. One or both of you is unsure the other is in it for the long run, the mirror of the first sign above. (Joel and colleagues, 2020)
These describe patterns, not people.
Is a problem that never goes away a sign of incompatibility?
Not on its own. John Gottman's research reports that about 69 percent of couples' conflicts are perpetual, rooted in lasting differences, rather than solvable. The Institute's concern is less the difference itself than whether the two of you can still talk about it.
Can incompatible people make it work?
Some do. The Gottman Institute treats repair, not the absence of conflict, as the thing to watch, which is why failed repairs sit on the second list and not every argument does. Across 43 studies, Joel and colleagues (2020) could not predict from any of the answers which relationships would improve and which would decline. So a list like this one describes where a couple stands today. It cannot say where they will be.
How can you test your compatibility?
The five-question checker on the compatibility calculator page asks what you know about the other person and points you to the right test, from a name game to the couple quiz. Only the couple quiz reads your relationship; the others are games or traditions, and each is labelled as one.
Sources
Studies and papers
- Joel, Eastwick and colleagues (2020), Machine learning uncovers the most robust self-report predictors of relationship quality across 43 longitudinal couples studies: PNAS 117(32); the five strongest relationship judgments
- Luo and Klohnen (2005), Assortative mating and marital quality in newlyweds: Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 88(2); 291 newlywed couples
- Montoya, Horton and Kirchner (2008), Is actual similarity necessary for attraction?: Journal of Social and Personal Relationships 25(6); meta-analysis of 313 studies
Organisations and other pages
- The Gottman Institute, The Four Horsemen: Criticism, Contempt, Defensiveness, and Stonewalling: The four names; contempt as the single greatest predictor of divorce
- The Gottman Institute, R is for Repair (2014): The definition of a repair attempt and the failure of repair
- The Gottman Institute, Research: Couples: Source of the 69 percent perpetual problems figure